Shark
Leonida's offshore danger. Your first one turns up during Kenton's dive in Island Dreams.
Your introduction to sharks comes early. In the Chapter 1 mission Island Dreams, PowerPyx and VGC both say a shark appears as you lead a bachelor party back from a shipwreck dive, and you are prompted to equip a harpoon. PowerPyx calls it the Arras Bullhead and says two hits drive the shark off. VGC warns that the spear gun's shots arc a lot, so get close before firing. PowerPyx says you can choose not to shoot, which costs one of the divers his life but has no lasting consequences. Mashable reports hammerhead sharks among the marine life after launch, and Polygon lists sharks in Rockstar's pre-launch roster.
Sources: PowerPyx ↗, VGC ↗, Mashable ↗, Polygon ↗