Pegassi Infernus ('96)
A '90s Pegassi supercar on Randy's list, parked high in a police station car park.
PowerPyx lists the Pegassi Infernus on Randy's original Wish List, and Output Lag and Destructoid call it the '96 Infernus. Push Square found it on the seventh level of the Crosstown Police Station car park on NW 9th St: wait for a cop to open the gate, sneak up, clone the key, and use the stunt jump on the top floor to escape. It has a tracker, so keep your speed up. Game Checklists confirms the spot. Destructoid and GamingBolt instead point to the garage of a white house in Capri; GamingBolt lists that car as the 'Pegassi '96' in the Sports Classics class.
How to get it
Sneak into the Crosstown Police Station car park, clone the key on level 7 and jump off the roof.
Sources: PowerPyx ↗, Output Lag ↗, Destructoid ↗, Push Square ↗, Game Checklists ↗, GamingBolt ↗