Pfister Comet S2
The fastest sports car by stock rating (7.7), beating several supercars.
GameSpot calls the Comet S2 the surprise of its top five: a sports car, not a supercar, rated 7.7 stock. Beebom agrees on the rating, adds 8.0 acceleration and 7.6 handling, and says it leads the whole sports class. GameSpot only says it becomes available later in the story; Beebom is more specific, saying you pick it for Jason during the mission Company Cars (Speak to the Concierge), which guarantees one for your garage. Game Checklists notes it is listed separately from the older '88 Comet.
How to get it
Choose it during the story mission Company Cars, according to Beebom.
Sources: GameSpot ↗, Beebom ↗, Game Checklists ↗
More sports
All vehicles →Grotti Carbonizzare
A Ferrari-style grand tourer with excellent top speed, found in wealthy Vice City.
Invetero Coquette D10
A modern mid-engined sports car that Output Lag rates about as fast as the Carbonizzare.
Bravado Banshee
A sports coupe on Randy's list, parked outside a Capri motel late at night.
Pfister Comet ('88)
An '88 sports coupe rated 6.1, parked at a Capri mansion.
Annis Elegy ('90)
A '90s sports coupe rated 5.5, with a GTA+ widebody version.
Maibatsu Penumbra FF ('97)
A '97 coupe; a green one styled like a street-racing film car sits in a Vespucci Island garage.